高牆與刺絲網圍成的監獄是司法制度最終站,是刑罰的執行處,是法治教育成敗的體現之地,也是犯罪人受矯治及庇護之所,身處司法體系最下游的我,反復思索著何謂自由?什麼是法治?國家人權的最底線到哪?犯罪的定義是什麼?刑罰的意義又何在?並試圖從中拼湊出正義的輪廓⋯⋯ The Humanity Experiment: Kind and Evil; the tug-of-war between justice and injustice; the competition among humanity and penalty which are demonstrated repeatedly in the prison, the final destination of judicature, that is composed of law, high walls and barbed wire meshes.
Showing posts with label 一日一景. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 一日一景. Show all posts
風和日麗(未完成)
前兩天同仁轉達科長的意思,說要找我在夜勤同仁的常年教育時跟大家說明兩件事:一是三八制如何實施,二是司改國是會議開會開得如何。
司改國是會議可以在網路上找到會議錄影、各個委員提出的意見書、會議紀錄、議決事項等各種資料,想了解都可以自己找來看。
傳聞矯正署已選定今年七月開始在宜蘭監獄示範三八制,若傳聞是真,這還真是我監所生涯十八年以來首次看到本署如此有效率的決策,司改國是會議真的沒白開呀!
科長談判技巧享譽全國又這麼有心,不如由科長出面斡旋本署裡勤務規劃專案小組到場說明,並接受同仁提問,選宜蘭示範考量的重點是什麼?在人力不足的現況下又要如何實施?
最近警政署變革制服樣式的事正好可以做為矯正署改變勤務制度做借鏡,他們前置調查提供三種管道,讓第一線員警可以反映對制服的建議,第一是在各地方警察機關選出基層代表的「通訊聯絡員」,負責收集機關內的建議,並參與專案小組會議,代表機關和警察發聲,第二是警察可以直接在臉書粉絲頁的貼文下留言,也可以私訊;第三是透過網路表單填寫,意見彙整後再交由專案小組研議。
矯正署黃俊棠署長於司改會議上再三強調我國獄政的公開透明,示範新勤務制度正好是展現監所透明化與民主決策的好機會,要是只在夜勤常年教育辦說明,格局這麼小很難成大事,我建議不僅要採納警政署對搜集基層意見的多元作法,更開放媒體要來個網路直播的焦點座談,廣邀全國各監所基層同仁、勞權學者、警消勞權團體(因目前監所還沒有勞權團體)、人權團體(如司改會或台權會,因為監所人員勞動狀況不僅屬勞動權益,相對也會影響受刑人)等等,匯集各方意見,一起來談談怎麼做規劃和示範,若示範的過程也要了解會出什麼問題,大家一起來監控,遇到問題時來調整作法,重點其實不在於非要三八制不可,而是要能設計出一套能徹底解決夜勤隔日制超時、過勞、薪資被苛扣等問題的新制度,那才會是可長可久之道。
圖:風和日麗(未完成)
妻子們離開時2017.03.29鋼筆+毛筆
近傍晚,妻子們一個個步出了懇親舍,而她們的丈夫們,則在同仁的戒護下,再次被銬上戒具,接著魚貫地上警備車,結束了午后的溫存⋯⋯
這當然不是每位受刑人都能有的待遇,得要表現良好,而且還有非執行殘刑的第一級受刑人,且無另案在偵查審理中者,也沒有強制工作或感訓處分待執行等資格上的限制,再經各級管教人員應逐項審核簽註意見,送呈典獄長核定,提監務會議議決,申請核准後,若是妻子未能於指定時間內前來懇親,則以以棄權論,丈夫在三個月內不得再提出申請⋯⋯
每每看見監獄人妻們來懇親,總是既為他們高興又難過,經過多年,才能在那小小的房間裡擁有短短三小時的溫存時光,我想起以前在泰源技訓所時,那兒懇親舍的空間容納得下一整家子的人,看到妻子帶著孩子甚至公婆,來和丈夫共度整個週末的天倫之樂,那應該是短暫的幸福吧!
為什麼只有男受刑人?怎都沒看到女監的女受刑人去懇親舍?
不知道耶!不知是不是怕她們懷孕⋯⋯
這當然不是每位受刑人都能有的待遇,得要表現良好,而且還有非執行殘刑的第一級受刑人,且無另案在偵查審理中者,也沒有強制工作或感訓處分待執行等資格上的限制,再經各級管教人員應逐項審核簽註意見,送呈典獄長核定,提監務會議議決,申請核准後,若是妻子未能於指定時間內前來懇親,則以以棄權論,丈夫在三個月內不得再提出申請⋯⋯
每每看見監獄人妻們來懇親,總是既為他們高興又難過,經過多年,才能在那小小的房間裡擁有短短三小時的溫存時光,我想起以前在泰源技訓所時,那兒懇親舍的空間容納得下一整家子的人,看到妻子帶著孩子甚至公婆,來和丈夫共度整個週末的天倫之樂,那應該是短暫的幸福吧!
為什麼只有男受刑人?怎都沒看到女監的女受刑人去懇親舍?
不知道耶!不知是不是怕她們懷孕⋯⋯
黃溫恭~天倫夢
一年前,蔡瑞月舞蹈研究社的大蕭老師為了人權舞展,介紹我和小p到國家人權博物館籌備處看「遲來的愛-白色恐怖時期受難者遺書特展」,並邀我為受難前輩們作畫。記得看展那天台北天氣還不錯,我們倆夫婦看著一封封的遺書,心情也越來越沈重,尤其在黃溫恭前輩的遺書前面站得特別久,我花了很多時間看照片,但並不知道為什麼⋯⋯
另一個展廳展出政治受難者陳武鎮老師的油畫,同是政治受難者的郭振純前輩帶我們坐下來,他拿出陳武鎮老師畫冊《判決書》讓我細細看⋯⋯
突如其來的午後雷震雨,我和小p全身溼透,涉著及膝的積水離開,臉上除了雨水,還有淚⋯⋯
接下來的日子,我邊讀著前輩們生平和遺書,也上網找相關的影音資料,常常邊看邊流著淚,但不知要怎麼下筆⋯⋯
後來我發現,只要在心裡默默問他們:「請告訴我,希望我怎麼畫你?」立刻靈光乍現,下筆有如神助⋯⋯
另一個展廳展出政治受難者陳武鎮老師的油畫,同是政治受難者的郭振純前輩帶我們坐下來,他拿出陳武鎮老師畫冊《判決書》讓我細細看⋯⋯
突如其來的午後雷震雨,我和小p全身溼透,涉著及膝的積水離開,臉上除了雨水,還有淚⋯⋯
接下來的日子,我邊讀著前輩們生平和遺書,也上網找相關的影音資料,常常邊看邊流著淚,但不知要怎麼下筆⋯⋯
後來我發現,只要在心裡默默問他們:「請告訴我,希望我怎麼畫你?」立刻靈光乍現,下筆有如神助⋯⋯
展場裡黃溫恭前輩的全家福照片,不是小女兒黃春蘭尚未出生,就是黃溫恭已被槍決,黃溫恭被捕時,黃春蘭還在媽媽肚子裡,黃家從來沒有一張是真正的全家福,所以我決定讓他們在畫中團圓⋯⋯
舞展當天,我將畫送給了黃溫恭先生的小女兒黃春蘭教授,結束時我看見他們一家人帶著畫到黃溫恭先生的遺書前留影⋯⋯
《黃溫恭~天倫夢》,是我畫過最有意義的其中一幅畫,也是第一幅讓自己感動的作品⋯⋯
紀念228,記得白色恐怖,希望轉型正義的到來,不是為了恨,而是愛⋯

圖:黃溫恭天倫夢
鎮靜室的難兄難弟2017.02.25鋼筆+毛筆
無論是對收容人或是管理員,鎮靜室對雙方來說都是一場噩夢,這裡是監獄裡衛生條作最差的地方,若再搭配腳鐐和手梏施用,人道這種東西應該是一種神話,你會看到人被鍊在牆角,便溺不是在水桶裡,而是在棉被上⋯⋯
會來這裡的,真正頑劣的很少,絕大部份都有病,因為講也講不聽,聽也聽不懂,自然就因難管而不管,所以管理上秉持三不原則:
不理他!
不理他!
不理他!
除了三餐送飯,任誰都不會想進去裡面。
這算是必要之惡嗎⋯⋯
別再問了,我⋯⋯不知道⋯⋯
會來這裡的,真正頑劣的很少,絕大部份都有病,因為講也講不聽,聽也聽不懂,自然就因難管而不管,所以管理上秉持三不原則:
不理他!
不理他!
不理他!
除了三餐送飯,任誰都不會想進去裡面。
這算是必要之惡嗎⋯⋯
別再問了,我⋯⋯不知道⋯⋯
慘綠人生 2017.01.20Winkpen
A Miserable “Green” Life
Wink Pen 2017.01.20.
The sight of a new client in the pacification ward always makes me feel deeply sorry for their near future - they are going to be confined in a ward with filthy smell, inadequate ventilation and sanitation until they become “emotionally stable” and additional guard and control are no longer needed. Legs are still shackled. The face, being out of the sun for too long, is turning pale, or even green, just like the green walls. “Miserable green” is not intended for such an expression but I’m at my wit’s end and can’t find a suitable word for the situation he’s in.
Green tarpaulin covers the yellow foam pasted on the walls in the pacification ward, which is a standard specification to keep inmates from self-mutilation and self-injury. Does it work? No necessarily. There was a pacification ward in Taitung. Years ago a psychotic inmate hit the toilet bowl with his head and then took a sharp broken piece to cut himself. The prison removed the bowl and covered the feces pit with an army blanket. The ward was then filled with free particles of the smell from the septic tank underneath. The self-mutilating inmate couldn’t find anything to cut himself but another psychotic went mad. He lifted the blanket and started eating feces.
每次看到鎮靜室來了新客戶,心裡總是無比感慨,接下來的日子他們就得待在這間氣味、通風及衛生皆不佳的牢房裡,直到他們「情緒穩定」,無戒護安全之顧為止,腳上還鎖著腳鐐,那缺乏日照而日益蒼白的臉,開始反射出牆面的綠色時,雖然明知道「慘綠」兩字不該這麼用,但我還是真想不出能用什麼詞彙來形容這樣的處境⋯⋯ 為了防止收容人自殘自傷,牆面貼滿黃色泡棉,泡棉表面再糊上綠色的帆布,這是鎮靜室的標準規格,但有用嗎?未必,多年前台東某單位的鎮靜室,就因一個用腦門和馬桶比硬,又拿馬桶碎片自傷的精神病患,而把馬桶全拆了,只用一條軍毯蓋在屎坑上,化糞池的臭味也就自自冉冉瀰漫著,自殘的收容人是沒東西拿來劃自己了,可另一個精神病患發了病,卻掀開毯子挖糞往嘴裡送⋯⋯
Wink Pen 2017.01.20.
The sight of a new client in the pacification ward always makes me feel deeply sorry for their near future - they are going to be confined in a ward with filthy smell, inadequate ventilation and sanitation until they become “emotionally stable” and additional guard and control are no longer needed. Legs are still shackled. The face, being out of the sun for too long, is turning pale, or even green, just like the green walls. “Miserable green” is not intended for such an expression but I’m at my wit’s end and can’t find a suitable word for the situation he’s in.
Green tarpaulin covers the yellow foam pasted on the walls in the pacification ward, which is a standard specification to keep inmates from self-mutilation and self-injury. Does it work? No necessarily. There was a pacification ward in Taitung. Years ago a psychotic inmate hit the toilet bowl with his head and then took a sharp broken piece to cut himself. The prison removed the bowl and covered the feces pit with an army blanket. The ward was then filled with free particles of the smell from the septic tank underneath. The self-mutilating inmate couldn’t find anything to cut himself but another psychotic went mad. He lifted the blanket and started eating feces.
每次看到鎮靜室來了新客戶,心裡總是無比感慨,接下來的日子他們就得待在這間氣味、通風及衛生皆不佳的牢房裡,直到他們「情緒穩定」,無戒護安全之顧為止,腳上還鎖著腳鐐,那缺乏日照而日益蒼白的臉,開始反射出牆面的綠色時,雖然明知道「慘綠」兩字不該這麼用,但我還是真想不出能用什麼詞彙來形容這樣的處境⋯⋯ 為了防止收容人自殘自傷,牆面貼滿黃色泡棉,泡棉表面再糊上綠色的帆布,這是鎮靜室的標準規格,但有用嗎?未必,多年前台東某單位的鎮靜室,就因一個用腦門和馬桶比硬,又拿馬桶碎片自傷的精神病患,而把馬桶全拆了,只用一條軍毯蓋在屎坑上,化糞池的臭味也就自自冉冉瀰漫著,自殘的收容人是沒東西拿來劃自己了,可另一個精神病患發了病,卻掀開毯子挖糞往嘴裡送⋯⋯
阿公的家書2017.01.27鋼筆
Grand-dad’s Letters
Fountain Pen Drawing 2017.01.27.
It’s the visitation on Chinese New Year’s eve. The family of the elderly inmate do not come. He also knows that they will not show for the visitation on the third day after the New Year. They have discussed and agreed that he doesn’t want his family to waste the holidays in traffic jams. But he really misses his lovely granddaughter. He turns to pen and paper and writes down how much he misses her.
除夕開放接見,不過家人沒來,老人家心裡明白,初三的接見他們也不會出現,這是先前已經講好的,因為他不希望家人把難得的春節連假,花在塞車裡,不過他實在想念可愛的小孫女,於是提起筆,寫下對她滿滿的思念⋯⋯
Fountain Pen Drawing 2017.01.27.
It’s the visitation on Chinese New Year’s eve. The family of the elderly inmate do not come. He also knows that they will not show for the visitation on the third day after the New Year. They have discussed and agreed that he doesn’t want his family to waste the holidays in traffic jams. But he really misses his lovely granddaughter. He turns to pen and paper and writes down how much he misses her.
除夕開放接見,不過家人沒來,老人家心裡明白,初三的接見他們也不會出現,這是先前已經講好的,因為他不希望家人把難得的春節連假,花在塞車裡,不過他實在想念可愛的小孫女,於是提起筆,寫下對她滿滿的思念⋯⋯
早課2017.01.26鋼筆
Morning Recitation
Fountain Pen Drawing 2017.01.26.
Morning rise is for reciting Buddhist classics.
Cross-legs hurt and muscles unease.
Dreams is the only warm place in chill winter.
Better practices to be found in a comforter.
晨起早課為唸經
盤腿好痛筋好硬
寒冬唯剩夢鄉暖
包著棉被好修行
Fountain Pen Drawing 2017.01.26.
Morning rise is for reciting Buddhist classics.
Cross-legs hurt and muscles unease.
Dreams is the only warm place in chill winter.
Better practices to be found in a comforter.
晨起早課為唸經
盤腿好痛筋好硬
寒冬唯剩夢鄉暖
包著棉被好修行
媽媽我愛妳2017.01.25鋼筆
I Love you, Mom.
Fountain Pen Drawing 2017.01.25.
It is going to be the Chinese New Year in two days. The little patch of the blue sky outside of the iron bars has taken the little one’s full attention. This is his second new year in the prison and there will be the third and the fourth. He came to realize, after finishing the first new year, that it made little difference to him spending it on either side of the prison.
He misses home and the hugs from his mother. However, when he got home, his mother lashed out at him, bashed him and threw him out. After he left home broken-hearted, she called the police telling on his runaway. The recurrence of the incidents made him suspect his mother’s love for him.
His wandering ended in the prison. His mother comes for visits and tells how much she loves him. “This way is better,” He reckons.
再兩天就要過年了,鐵窗外那一小片藍天,讓阿弟看到出神,這是他在監獄裡過的第二個年,未來還有有第三個、第四個,在過完第一個年以後,他就發現在外面過年和在監獄裡過,對他來說其實沒兩樣⋯⋯
Fountain Pen Drawing 2017.01.25.
It is going to be the Chinese New Year in two days. The little patch of the blue sky outside of the iron bars has taken the little one’s full attention. This is his second new year in the prison and there will be the third and the fourth. He came to realize, after finishing the first new year, that it made little difference to him spending it on either side of the prison.
He misses home and the hugs from his mother. However, when he got home, his mother lashed out at him, bashed him and threw him out. After he left home broken-hearted, she called the police telling on his runaway. The recurrence of the incidents made him suspect his mother’s love for him.
His wandering ended in the prison. His mother comes for visits and tells how much she loves him. “This way is better,” He reckons.
再兩天就要過年了,鐵窗外那一小片藍天,讓阿弟看到出神,這是他在監獄裡過的第二個年,未來還有有第三個、第四個,在過完第一個年以後,他就發現在外面過年和在監獄裡過,對他來說其實沒兩樣⋯⋯
他想家,很渴望媽媽的懷抱,但他不懂,為何每次一回到家,媽媽就會打啊罵啊的,把他攆出家門,當他哭著離開,她卻又打電話求他回來,然後報警說他逃家,這事一次次發生,他都不曉得媽媽究竟愛不愛他⋯⋯
進了監獄,他再也不必流浪了,而且媽媽都會來看他,說她有多愛他⋯⋯
「這樣比較好⋯⋯」他說。
進了監獄,他再也不必流浪了,而且媽媽都會來看他,說她有多愛他⋯⋯
「這樣比較好⋯⋯」他說。
輪椅上的老人家2017.01.24鋼筆
The Elderly in Wheelchairs
Fountain Pen Drawing 2017.01.24.
Medical affairs of prisons have been accepted by the National Health Insurance 2.0. Despite some improvements, the root causes for old problems still remain unaddressed. For instance, the media has been focusing on how money and power influence the approval of medical treatment on bails. There are other issues. The questions about how sick inmates are treated rise behind the death of an inmate inside a prison. There is the issue about the long-term care for the elderly and the seriously ill inmates who have committed serious crimes. No maximum is imposed on solitary confinement. There are not on-site medical staff on holidays to decide whether an sick inmate should be admitted to the emergency. There is violation about drug being dispensed against the rules by prison controllers. The medical affairs in prisons have always had problems and should been handled by the Ministry of Health. But the Agency of Corrections don’t want to let go, so the Ministry of Health continue pretending there are no problems.
老人家又坐在輪椅上從病舍被推出來看診了,受刑人納入二代健保後,收容人看診及外醫的人數增加,監所醫療看似有大幅度的改變,但長久以來的問題在根本上其實仍是無解⋯⋯
保外就醫的審核標準常隨權貴搖擺,大概是最常被媒體報導的⋯⋯
因收容人在監所內死亡,疑雲背後所帶出的疾患收容人如何被對待⋯⋯
那重刑化之下,老齡及重病收容人未來的長照問題呢⋯⋯
獨居監禁毫無期限限制的問題呢⋯⋯
假日無醫療人員駐守以判斷收容人是否急診的問題呢⋯⋯
還有監所管理員違法發藥的問題呢⋯⋯
一直做不好的監所醫療不是早該由衛福部接手,不過矯正署似乎沒放手的意思,衛福部也一直裝作沒看到⋯⋯
我想起2014年參加監所改革論壇時,對於我提的發藥及獨居問題,台上長官回答說遠距視訊接見是他做的⋯⋯
台上坐著位中年女子,一直沒參與發言,我一直當是買菜大嬸走錯地方,桌上名牌寫的是心口司司長,這樣當官應該是快樂的吧⋯⋯
Fountain Pen Drawing 2017.01.24.
Medical affairs of prisons have been accepted by the National Health Insurance 2.0. Despite some improvements, the root causes for old problems still remain unaddressed. For instance, the media has been focusing on how money and power influence the approval of medical treatment on bails. There are other issues. The questions about how sick inmates are treated rise behind the death of an inmate inside a prison. There is the issue about the long-term care for the elderly and the seriously ill inmates who have committed serious crimes. No maximum is imposed on solitary confinement. There are not on-site medical staff on holidays to decide whether an sick inmate should be admitted to the emergency. There is violation about drug being dispensed against the rules by prison controllers. The medical affairs in prisons have always had problems and should been handled by the Ministry of Health. But the Agency of Corrections don’t want to let go, so the Ministry of Health continue pretending there are no problems.
老人家又坐在輪椅上從病舍被推出來看診了,受刑人納入二代健保後,收容人看診及外醫的人數增加,監所醫療看似有大幅度的改變,但長久以來的問題在根本上其實仍是無解⋯⋯
保外就醫的審核標準常隨權貴搖擺,大概是最常被媒體報導的⋯⋯
因收容人在監所內死亡,疑雲背後所帶出的疾患收容人如何被對待⋯⋯
那重刑化之下,老齡及重病收容人未來的長照問題呢⋯⋯
獨居監禁毫無期限限制的問題呢⋯⋯
假日無醫療人員駐守以判斷收容人是否急診的問題呢⋯⋯
還有監所管理員違法發藥的問題呢⋯⋯
一直做不好的監所醫療不是早該由衛福部接手,不過矯正署似乎沒放手的意思,衛福部也一直裝作沒看到⋯⋯
我想起2014年參加監所改革論壇時,對於我提的發藥及獨居問題,台上長官回答說遠距視訊接見是他做的⋯⋯
台上坐著位中年女子,一直沒參與發言,我一直當是買菜大嬸走錯地方,桌上名牌寫的是心口司司長,這樣當官應該是快樂的吧⋯⋯
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








